Thursday, June 10, 2021

On unpublished and unpublishable work

On Twitter, essayist Paul Crenshaw asks

What’s the collective noun for all your unpublished pieces, the detritus and debris from writing, the cast-offs and castaways languishing on their little file of an island?

One of the team members at Pen & Anvil -- and why DO so many people have access to our social media account? -- pinged my handle in a reply, taking the view, I suppose, that this is the sort of question I'd have fun in answering. They were right! Here is my reply

I resent that you think I think about this a lot. Though, I do. Viz: Jeofails. Compost. Hellboxlings. Bad jokes. Benthic snow. Sequestra. Woundikins. Pendlings. Beneficiaries of no one's orphanotrophism. Dead squibs. Pulp cabinet. Diple heap. Hobobooks. Ye olde parapraxial hoard.

Of course I think about this a lot. Most of my writings are stillborn. My rate of return on personal poetry submissions is.... not a number I wish to quote here. Those writings that do survive the rigors and wrenchings of gestation and birth most often turn out to be not suited for life. Those, I allow to wither and perish -- sports, errors of the lineage. They would only be rejected by editors, rightly so. Kill your darlings, friends, and weep not for unadopted children. Writing is a brutal art. 

Do check out all the replies in Crenshaw's original thread -- some really lovely metaphors and phrasings are on display!